Critical Friend Rubric

Home
Syllabus
Schedule
Links


Critical Friend:  _____________________________________________________

Please be a critical friend and carefully read and analyze your partner’s paper.  Mark the draft where appropriate and make comments below.  Cite problems in the comments.  For example:  "paragraph 2 sentence 4."  Use the back of this page to make additional comments.  Remember that you do not have to agree with what the paper says – just understand it. 

STRUCTURE/CONTENT

YES

NO

COMMENTS

Includes elements required

 

 

 

Introduction citing the article and telling what paper is about.

 

 

 

Closing paragraph summarizes points made in body

 

 

 

Describes the method and design of the study.

 

 

 

Describes the procedures used by the researchers.

 

 

 

Results - present statistical findings and conclusions of the author(s)

 

 

 

Discussion - summarizes the author's discussion of the results

 

 

 

Conclusion - end with a discussion of what you learned from the article

 

 

 

References cited

 

 

 

Flows smoothly and logically from one thought to the next

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

PUNCTUATION/SPELLING

 

 

 

All words spelled correctly

 

 

 

Check use of there, their, they’re

 

 

 

A lot is two words

 

 

 

Check use of to, too, two

 

 

 

Check use of then, than

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

GRAMMAR

 

 

 

Sentences are complete

 

 

 

Noun/verb agreement

 

 

 

Noun/pronoun agreement

 

 

 

Few sentences begin with I

 

 

 

STYLE

Follows APA style guidelines

Teacher Education Homepage

email Dr. Schulz